One basic but difficult truth in the Christian faith is this: we can’t always interpret or understand providence. We sometimes have no idea why certain things happened when they did; we don’t know why they happened how they did. This fact stretches and tests our faith. Why did my kids get terribly ill but no one else’s did? Why did God allow my parents to get into a car accident and sustain life-threatening injuries? How come there are people getting laid off at work, and am I next? Sometimes we just can’t understand, interpret, or read God’s sovereign providence. John Flavel (d.1691) gave wise counsel that the child of God should not pry into his Father’s providence:
Do not pry too curiously into the secrets of Providence, nor allow your shallow reason arrogantly to judge and censure its designs.
There are hard texts in the works as well as in the Word of God. It becomes us modestly and humbly to show reverence, but not to dogmatize too boldly and positively upon them. A man may easily get a strain by over-reaching. ‘When I thought to know this,’ said Asaph, ‘it was too painful for me’ (Psalm 73:16). ‘I thought to know this’ – there was the arrogant attempt of reason, there he pried into the arcana of Providence – ‘but it was too wonderful for me,’ it was ‘useless labour,’ as Calvin expounds it. He pried so far into that puzzling mystery of the afflictions of the righteous and prosperity of the wicked, till it begat envy towards them and despondency in himself (Psalm 73:3, 13), and this was all he got by summoning Providence to the bar of reason. Holy Job was guilty of this evil, and frankly ashamed of it (Job 42:3).
I know there is nothing in the Word or in the works of God that is repugnant to sound reason, but there are some things in both which are opposite to carnal reason, as well as above right reason; and therefore our reason never shows itself more unreasonable than in summoning those things to its bar which transcend its sphere and capacity. Many are the mischiefs which ensue upon this practice.
Indeed. The secret things belong to the Lord, but the things he revealed belong to us and to our children (Deut. 29:29). And, as has been said before, even though the child of God cannot always trace the ways of his Father, he can always trust him!
The above quote is found on page 141 of The Mystery of Providence.
Covenant Presbyterian Church (OPC)
Hammond, WI, 54015