Justice Pursued with Hatred? (Guinness)

carpe diem cover image

Many people today have a skewed view of justice. Some think justice has to do with violence and revenge. Others think that justice allows people to say and do terrible things. Still others believe that justice means they can disobey laws and ignore order. Speaking of justice, true justice does not have hatred for its fuel. Os Guinness makes this great point in chapter five of his 2019 book Carpe Diem Redeemed. Here’s the quote (the emphasis below is mine):

…Hatred poisons society and holds the hater captive as mercilessly as any ancient Pharaoh, Southern overseer, modern tyrant, or sexual predator.  Will the United States ever transcend racism and sexism?  Certainly not through the ways in which racial and sexual politics are being waged now.

Booker T. Washington exemplified the way of the gospel in shining contrast with many of today’s racial and sexual activists.  Freed by Abraham Lincoln from slavery in Franklin County, Virginia, Washington was remarkable for his complete absence of any bitterness.  ‘I was resolved,’ he wrote, ‘that I would permit no  man, no matter what his color might be, to narrow and degrade my soul by making me hate him…I pity from the bottom of my heart any individual who is so unfortunate as to get into the habit of holding race predjudice.’  In strong contrast, he wrote, there were those then (and there are those today) who make it their business to  keep stoking racial wrongs in the public square.  ‘Some of these people do not want the Negro to lose his grievances because they do not want to lose their jobs.’

Born in slavery and facing the dark rise of the Ku Klux Klan, Booker T. Washington knew the degradation of slavery all too well and hated it as an institution – as we should hate racism today.  The stark contrast between the spirit of such great African American champions and that of many of today’s racial activists is stunning.  These great ex-slaves and oppponents of slavery knew that freedom that begins in the heart must never issue in hate, whereas activism that is not free in the heart only compounds hate even as it claims to fight hate.  Justice pursued with hate leads only to more evil and even greater injustice.  To be reconciling and restorative, justice must be pursued with an eye to the possibility of genuine repentance, genuine forgiveness, and genuine reconciliation – and thus with hearts that are freed from bitterness.

The past is always present.  It is certainly not dead.  But forgiveness and reconciliation can draw the poison out of hate so that the past no longer kills the present but liberates it to go forward freely into the future.  Through repentance and forgiveness, the poison is prevented from spreading.  The ball and chain is broken.  Reaction needs no longer follow action.  Even before the end of time, the past can be redeemed in part, with the evil acknowledged and contained.

Os Guinness, Carpe Diem Redeemed, p. 95-6.

Shane Lems
Hammond, WI, 54015

3 thoughts on “Justice Pursued with Hatred? (Guinness)”

  1. I would be interested in Guinness’s understanding of Washington’s contemporary WEB Dubois on the subject of Justice. Or perhaps Frederick Douglass’ perspective.

    I find modern-day racial activists are more in line with the latter men and these men did not espouse hate, just accountability that leads to genuine repentance like what Guinness calls for.

    Who are these “many of today’s racial activists” running on hate, Guinness is talking about? Does he name them in his book?

    This excerpt does not encourage me to read Guinness on this subject, though I respect him greatly.

    Like

    1. Thanks for the comment and feedback. Yes, there is a larger context to the quote I put here. If you’ve read/heard Guinness before and respect him, I’m sure you’d find the larger context of this quote helpful.

      Like

Comments are closed.